Wildguzzi.com

General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: slowmover on July 30, 2016, 08:02:55 PM

Title: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: slowmover on July 30, 2016, 08:02:55 PM
Changed oil in the 2013 Stone today. Opened front and back plugs and let her drain for hours.Replaced filter and put in 2 liters Eni-Agip and it's one half inch over the top of the checkered area of the stick when just pushed in and not screwed in .Yes the bike is level.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 30, 2016, 08:08:12 PM
You changed the oil filter too, yes?

Edit autocorrect is my enema!
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: slowmover on July 30, 2016, 08:36:22 PM
Yes new filter.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: rodekyll on July 30, 2016, 08:43:45 PM
Did you fill the new filter?
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: rtbickel on July 30, 2016, 08:47:28 PM
Give it a few turns with the starter to prime the filter then check it again.   Is this a V7 or 1100?  If 1100, there is one drain on the back side of the pan and 2 on the trans.  Did you drop the pan to change the filter?.  Not familiar with the underside of a V7 though.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 30, 2016, 09:01:02 PM

See edit - autocorrect is my enema!  :boozing:

Give it a few turns with the starter to prime the filter then check it again.   Is this a V7 or 1100?  If 1100, there is one drain on the back side of the pan and 2 on the trans.  Did you drop the pan to change the filter?.  Not familiar with the underside of a V7 though.


2013 Stone = V7
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: slowmover on July 30, 2016, 09:01:55 PM
How do you fill a canister filter? Never had to do it before. I figure at some point it would become saturated.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 30, 2016, 09:02:57 PM
How do you fill a canister filter? Never had to do it before. I figure at some point it would become saturated.

Crank the motor or run it. I assume you did that before checking oil level yes?
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: slowmover on July 30, 2016, 09:27:10 PM
I rode it for 20 minutes before i checked it again. Hey Kev did you change your spark plug caps as per the discussion earlier this week?
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 30, 2016, 09:34:38 PM
I rode it for 20 minutes before i checked it again. Hey Kev did you change your spark plug caps as per the discussion earlier this week?

Come to think of it, was the stock capacity actually 1.9L?

Honestly, I don't care what the spec says, oil change 101 is that many specs are for a dry motor. Always refill gradually, checking level often, and don't be surprised if you can't put the full spec in. Sure, some motors will take full spec, but others no way.

As for spark plugs caps, nope....I live by the moto that if it "ain't broke" don't fix it.

But I'll be cautious handling them moving forward. Might even pick up spares.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: slowmover on July 30, 2016, 09:48:29 PM
122.05 cu in(2000 cc) per manual
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Muzz on July 31, 2016, 12:38:41 AM
.I live by the moto that if it "ain't broke" don't fix it.


Wise words there Kev. :1: :thumb:
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 31, 2016, 04:47:53 AM
122.05 cu in(2000 cc) per manual

Then see second comment about specs and dry motors (after rebuild vs oil change).

Unfortunately I can't add to this from experience with the V7 stock capacity since I added a sump spacer right away and that changed capacity. Moreover it added "about" a liter, give or take, and my capacity is now somewhere around 2.75Lish

I know I've always got some fraction of a liter left over, and beer I would have without the spacer too.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Chuck in Indiana on July 31, 2016, 07:44:55 AM
Quote
Sure, some motors will take full spec, but others no way.
<scratching head> They are all built off the same tooling..
Has anyone actually *looked* at how the small block filter works? It fits in a cylindrical cavity. The oil pump picks up oil from the sump and sends it to this cavity. It has to completely fill this cavity before heading on to the bearings, etc. It takes a fair amount of oil to do this. Naturally, if you drain all the oil and empty that cavity by changing the filter, then pour in the correct amount of oil it will read high on the dipstick until the oil pump fills the oil filter cavity. <shrug> It isn't rocket science.
Edit:
Here's a picture of the oil filter cavity.
http://i29.photobucket.com/albums/c294/elwood59/aero%20engine/1-016_zps0e8864e9.jpg
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: sib on July 31, 2016, 07:49:37 AM
on my V7II Stone, when I change the oil every 6214 mi (10,000 km), I put in a new filter and 2 1-liter bottles of the proper oil, screw in the filler/dipstick, and don't unscrew it again until the next oil change, when about 2 liters drains out.  There's no significant oil loss between changes, no significant oil accumulation in the air box, and there's never been any symptoms of being overfilled.  I ride more, fret less.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: guzzisteve on July 31, 2016, 07:59:27 AM
I've been putting in 1 1/2 qt, run bike & top off. Who cares how much! This method has worked flawlessly in BB & SB's since 1976. BB I put in 2 1/2qt.
It's just going to leak or get puked out anyway.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: stevet on July 31, 2016, 08:59:24 AM
on my V7II Stone, when I change the oil every 6214 mi (10,000 km)...  (chop text)

Holy cow, how many miles have you put on that new model?  Well done!

Steve.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: sib on July 31, 2016, 09:07:31 AM
Holy cow, how many miles have you put on that new model?  Well done!

Steve.
It's about time for the 20,000 km servicing.  I got the bike in May of last year, it was the first one delivered in RI, as far as I know.  I'm retired, so I can ride every day that the weather cooperates.  I really liked my previous '13 Stone, and I like the '16 Stone even more.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 31, 2016, 09:09:39 AM
<scratching head> They are all built off the same tooling..


You misunderstand my quote. I'm saying that industry wide some OEMs publish specs that are for oil change refill, some publish specs that are for a dry motor (rebuild) refill. So you can't always look at a spec and just dump that amount of oil into a motor after a change.

I think some, like some Hondas would publish 3 specs:

Dry motor refill
Oil change W/out filter.
Oil change W/ filter.

So over my career it has always been a case of fill gradually till within about 1 qt of spec, run motor to fill filter/circulate oil, top off via dipstick, and don't worry if it's not quite the same amount as spec.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: old as dirt 2 on July 31, 2016, 09:37:36 AM
I've been putting in 1 1/2 qt, run bike & top off. Who cares how much! This method has worked flawlessly in BB & SB's since 1976. BB I put in 2 1/2qt.
It's just going to leak or get puked out anyway.
I am in the same camp. never had an issue in 40 years of doing it this way. I also don't go quite full, about 90% full.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: stevet on July 31, 2016, 11:33:40 AM
So, changing the topic just a little bit, can someone give a solid explanation why my V7II (and those before it) needs to have the oil level checked when the engine is hot?  What is happening inside that block when the system is cold and I pull out the dipstick?  What problem or damage is caused with a cold oil level check?

Ain't no fun checking the oil level when everything there, including the dipstick, is just waiting to cook your flesh.  (Yeah, yeah, pull it out with a rag, put on gloves, etc.)

Seems more logical to check the oil level before I start the bike instead of running it for at least 10km (if I recall the manual properly), then checking and finding that I'm dangerously low on oil.  Fortunately, I've not lost a drop.  But there is oil in the air box condom and a film on the bottom of the airbox itself.

Steve.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: keener on July 31, 2016, 11:38:38 AM
What is the recommended  oil/ filter change intervals on a V7  10,000 km seems a bit high especially on 2 liters of oil ?
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Zinfan on July 31, 2016, 12:20:54 PM
So, changing the topic just a little bit, can someone give a solid explanation why my V7II (and those before it) needs to have the oil level checked when the engine is hot?  What is happening inside that block when the system is cold and I pull out the dipstick?  What problem or damage is caused with a cold oil level check?

Ain't no fun checking the oil level when everything there, including the dipstick, is just waiting to cook your flesh.  (Yeah, yeah, pull it out with a rag, put on gloves, etc.)

Seems more logical to check the oil level before I start the bike instead of running it for at least 10km (if I recall the manual properly), then checking and finding that I'm dangerously low on oil.  Fortunately, I've not lost a drop.  But there is oil in the air box condom and a film on the bottom of the airbox itself.

Steve.

I imagine the dipstick is marked based on the hot oil.  The answer is to check that the oil level is correct while hot then wait for it to cool down and then check it again and now you know the proper level when cold.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: v65tt on July 31, 2016, 01:36:07 PM
Sounds about right ... I just marked the dipstick after doing the oil and filter with the bike on the side stand sat on a level part of the drive

Using your own mark on the dipstick when you know you have 2 litres in the sump and its on the side stand makes regular checks so much easier

We put 2l in every v7 and never have problems
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on July 31, 2016, 04:49:56 PM
Man and I thought I was retentive ...

The oil change interval is fine, the level changes an RCH from expansion cold-to-hot.


Don't lose sleep over either!
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Cam3512 on July 31, 2016, 05:12:41 PM
I go rogue and check mine after screwing IN the stick.  I'm crazy like that.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: lucian on July 31, 2016, 06:01:10 PM
 I witnessed one marine mechanic take an involuntary swim when the boat captain asked weather or not he had pre filled the oil filters. I guess " what for" was the wrong answer. The boat had an open transom and off it he went, fortunately it was summer and the guy could swim with boots on.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: bmc5733946 on July 31, 2016, 07:04:16 PM
At one point in time Caterpillar and/or Cummins recommended against filling oil filters before installation because dirt could be introduced to the inside of the filter and therefore directly to the engine oiling system.  Working on heavy equipment I stopped doing it many, many years ago, there is enough oil still on the bearings to lube them while cranking.  According to the engineers who lead our training sessions, the highest load on the bearings is at startup, and no damage would be done if we prevented the engine from starting until the system filled the filters.  On diesels I shut off the fuel, on gas engines I remove spark.  To date I have not lost an engine and remember some filters are mounted upside down, how can you prefill those? Everybody do what pleases themselves and ride far and often!!

Brian
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Chuck in Indiana on August 01, 2016, 08:12:14 AM
^^^^^ this
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: sib on August 01, 2016, 08:36:44 AM
What is the recommended  oil/ filter change intervals on a V7  10,000 km seems a bit high especially on 2 liters of oil ?
It may seem high to you but that's the recommended interval.  Pre-1TB models had a specified 7500-km change interval.  I'm not sure whether the difference was due to different engine components or different oil ratings.

I once checked the oil level in my '13 V7 both hot and cold, and there was no significant difference in the level on the dipstick.  On the other hand, after sitting over winter (about 3 months), the cold oil level in my '16 V7II was a bit higher than when I had last checked, probably because oil in the filter (and maybe elsewhere in the engine as well) had slowly drained into the crankcase during the extended down time.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Dofin on August 01, 2016, 09:47:15 AM
Relatively new 2015 V7 stone owner.  I also posted this very same topic last month.  Changed oil measured 2 ltr per manual/filter change at 6.5K, warmed the engine a few laps around the block, checked oil per manual and the oil read about 3/8 inch over hash marks

After forum discussion I just marked the dip rod for indicated level. 

At 4K miles after oil change with with light oil misting of air box there has been no noticeable change in oil level on dip stick.

After some experiance with this bike and reading the forum I figure filling with proper amount of oil IAW manual at oil/filter change, check the oil every so often as I do with any machine with oil.  Still getting comfortable with the V7, so far it is pretty much like any new to me bike and that is a good thing I guess.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: tonUPRacer on August 01, 2016, 10:07:09 AM
122.05 cu in(2000 cc) per manual
I never put 2 full liters in, but then again I check on the side stand. I usually leave about 2 or 3 oz in the 2nd bottle and that keeps my level in the safe zone when checking on side stand. I do change the filter but don't pre-fill it. YMMV
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Chuck in Indiana on August 01, 2016, 10:28:34 AM
I can't imagine any way you *could* pre fill a small block filter..
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Cam3512 on August 01, 2016, 10:29:09 AM
There's no way to "pre fill" the filter in these engines. 

EDIT:  Beat me to it Chuck. Got the warning that someone else was posting at the exact same time!
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Chuck in Indiana on August 01, 2016, 10:31:22 AM
Just had a thought. You could turn the whole bike upside down like we used to do with our bicycles..  :smiley: Rest it on the handlebars and seat.  :cool:
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: sib on August 01, 2016, 10:35:13 AM
Just had a thought. You could turn the whole bike upside down like we used to do with our bicycles..  :smiley: Rest it on the handlebars and seat.  :cool:
Or, if you had some dilithium crystals around, you might be able to reverse gravity.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Kev m on August 01, 2016, 10:40:23 AM
As far as I'm concerned prefilling = priming or filling before running the motor or at least before checking final oil level.

So yes you can prefill/prime (though I don't know why you would) simply by turning the motor over by hand or using the starter with the ignition disabled (spark plug leads grounded).

But the real point in bringing it up was to make sure the oil filter was indeed full before declaring the motor overfilled after an oil change.

Jeezzz, you guys could make a fuss over anything.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: Dofin on August 01, 2016, 11:00:16 AM
True Dat!!   :Beating_A_Dead_Hors e_by_liviu   :grin:
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: normzone on August 01, 2016, 11:27:03 AM
Just had a thought. You could turn the whole bike upside down like we used to do with our bicycles..  :smiley: Rest it on the handlebars and seat.  :cool:

Yes, and performing both draining and filling the transmission and engine through the drain hole plugs helps to reduce wear on the dipstick threads as well.

 :Beating_A_Dead_Hors e_by_liviu
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: rodekyll on August 01, 2016, 01:22:54 PM
At one point in time Caterpillar and/or Cummins recommended against filling oil filters before installation because dirt could be introduced to the inside of the filter and therefore directly to the engine oiling system.  Working on heavy equipment I stopped doing it many, many years ago, there is enough oil still on the bearings to lube them while cranking.  According to the engineers who lead our training sessions, the highest load on the bearings is at startup, and no damage would be done if we prevented the engine from starting until the system filled the filters.  On diesels I shut off the fuel, on gas engines I remove spark.  To date I have not lost an engine and remember some filters are mounted upside down, how can you prefill those? Everybody do what pleases themselves and ride far and often!!

Brian

How is dirt going to get in the filter by pouring oil into the filter that wouldn't have gotten into the filter by pouring the same oil directly into the engine? 

Our marine diesels used element filters which displaced a gallon or more.  Can you imagine cranking a dry diesel engine for the minutes it would take until that filter can filled and the element soaked up enough oil to start passing any to the engine?  That's a LOT of unnecessary stress on the battery, starter, etc just to avoid hand-filling the filter.

But the comparison to a 6-oz guzzi filter isn't really fair.  Neither are complaints about upside down filters and the like.  The guzzi doesn't have any of that.  Pour oil into it.  Spin it on.
Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: bmc5733946 on August 01, 2016, 04:21:25 PM
RK as I said, do what you will.  I only reported what I learned in training from my employer and the manufacturer of many heavy diesels.  I'm not here to argue information is information.  Check out some of the oil forums and so on for arguments either way.  All I know is what I was taught and what I have experienced.  I suppose I've done it wrong for my whole career, guess it's a good thing I'm retired now so I can't damage any more engines.  Experiences in the world of engines, all kinds of engines vary greatly. Please understand that I only offered a different viewpoint for consideration, I can't stop anyone from prefilling or not.

Brian

Title: Re: Dipstick weirdness again
Post by: rodekyll on August 01, 2016, 05:34:58 PM
Not arguing with you, BMC.  Just offering that different engines and different filters might have different procedures.