Wildguzzi.com
General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: bobrebos on February 02, 2018, 09:04:25 AM
-
...or will the GPS on my Iphone be enough. My stand alone old GPS finally broke and I dont know if one will be required for the Alaska trip or if the Iphone will suffice?? Thanks....
-
What if you go down and your iPhone gets broken? Get a car GPS they are under a hundred for a refurb unit.
-
Insert the following in comments below: "I only use maps and so should you!"
The phone will work PROVIDING there is cell coverage. I don't think you can rely on that (I'm almost sure you cannot).
I would get a cheap GPS as a back up and some good maps as another backup.
I don't think you would need much of a GPS if you can read maps. It's not like there are a lot of intersections to get lost at on your way.
-
Map is best, there�s only one road! GPS will send you down dead end roads.
-
Spend your money on a device that can be used to locate you and lets you send a HELP signal to those concerned...check advrider.com for recommendations
-
Just had a few friends coming back from Deadhorse this year
They said Cell Reception is SHIT in Canada portion of land, but was excellent once you hit Alaska and switch to US cellular network.
Cell GPS has more updated map regarding to gas station, food, traffic updates.
HOWEVER, there were time their satellite based GPS were a lot more accurate especially when they go off road into the woods.
So ya, short answer to your short Q, yes, please bring a separated GPS when traveling to Deadhorse Alaska.
-
There are like 3 roads going up there in total. Once you get on the Dalton, well then...
I just printed off some map pages and kept them in my tank bag. It wasn't often that I needed to refer to them.
-
There are like 3 roads going up there in total. Once you get on the Dalton, well then...
I just printed off some map pages and kept them in my tank bag. It wasn't often that I needed to refer to them.
I ordered some Canada and Alaska maps so I should be good. That and an old car GPS for a back-up. If I get lost you can all read about me in the news! Woo Hoo....Alaska in June....here I come!!!!!!!!!!!
-
The phone will work PROVIDING there is cell coverage. I don't think you can rely on that (I'm almost sure you cannot).
I would get a cheap GPS as a back up and some good maps as another backup.
You do NOT need cell coverage for a phone GPS. Why do you think you do?
I have Android devices mounted in my vehicles with no cell service, they have great GPSs. All I need to do is load the maps on a memory card over WiFi beforehand. I have access to a number of great maps all loaded on my device. Some of them have great highway maps. Some have great offroad maps. Some have great highway routing features. Some have features that seek the twistiest roads between here and there. Some find the fastest. Some are just simple but detailed maps.
A regular GPS is lucky to have one mediocre map, and their idea of routing. If it is missing anything, too bad.
-
You do NOT need cell coverage for a phone GPS. Why do you think you do?
I have Android devices mounted in my vehicles with no cell service, they have great GPSs. All I need to do is load the maps on a memory card over WiFi beforehand. I have access to a number of great maps all loaded on my device. Some of them have great highway maps. Some have great offroad maps. Some have great highway routing features. Some have features that seek the twistiest roads between here and there. Some find the fastest. Some are just simple but detailed maps.
A regular GPS is lucky to have one mediocre map, and their idea of routing. If it is missing anything, too bad.
Wayne, what maps and apps are you using on your Android devices? ,
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
-
There are apps with downloadable maps and as pointed out cheap car satnav available. I have a garmin zumo which is a proper bike satnav. Its good for following a route but it is hopeless for browsing a map and planning a route, phone apps are much better for browsing a map.
-
Just had a few friends coming back from Deadhorse this year
They said Cell Reception is SHIT in Canada portion of land, but was excellent once you hit Alaska and switch to US cellular network.
Cell GPS has more updated map regarding to gas station, food, traffic updates.
HOWEVER, there were time their satellite based GPS were a lot more accurate especially when they go off road into the woods.
So ya, short answer to your short Q, yes, please bring a separated GPS when traveling to Deadhorse Alaska.
I take exception to the 'shit' comment :wink:. Whereas shit infers poor cell reception; there is none on the highways in Yukon. Well, except in weird little pockets where reception from towns seems to bounce.
For the traveller; you don't 'need' a gps any more than you 'need' a map as long as you stay on the main roads and can read road signs but you'll miss a few side trips. Having both map and gps makes travel a lot more comfortable.
I use mine (gps) as an odometer and time management device more than as a directional pointer.
-
I ordered some Canada and Alaska maps so I should be good. That and an old car GPS for a back-up. If I get lost you can all read about me in the news! Woo Hoo....Alaska in June....here I come!!!!!!!!!!!
If you plan to stop for more than fuel in Whitehorse, let me know. Would be glad to meet you.
It's great ridding here; enjoy.
-
I'd recommend a separate GPS.
A SPOT satellite tracker or similar device is highly recommended in case you need to get word out that you need help. As has been noted, your cell phone will not have reliable enough coverage to act as a safety device.
The cell phone GPS will work, AS LONG AS YOU USE AN APP WITH DOWNLOADED MAPS! (Get a decent sized MicroSD card to hold them.) I use Sygic on Android (Moto G5Plus), but I haven't tried it in remote areas of Canada yet so I'm unsure of its map quality there. It does show the Alaska Highway and in-town roads for places like Whitehorse and Tok, AK.
If you plan on using your phone in Canada check with your carrier re roaming charges - these can be hefty, particularly for data! If you have an unlocked phone, you can get a SIM card from a Canadian carrier after crossing the border - this may save you a bunch of money. Just remember to switch back to your US SIM card when you cross the border.
-
Wayne, what maps and apps are you using on your Android devices? ,
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
Often Google maps, of course, for finding POI. But that needs data generally. Waze for traffic, but again, in needs data.
For riding around the twisty roads, I like OSMand. It offers a number of map types. I even created my own display XML to make it more visible in sunlight with OLED displays.
I use CoPilot for long road trips. It just works.
I used to use Locus for off road trails. Haven't done that in a while though.
Kurviger and Motogo are good for finding twisty routes. Don't use them if you are in a hurry.
Maprika is great for just putting a dot on a map. You can download a lot of maps, like for national parks and such. You you can take a picture of any map you have, and it will locate you on that map. Good for hikers. Or just wondering how far you are from that overlook you like on the Blue Ridge.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
-
...or will the GPS on my Iphone be enough. My stand alone old GPS finally broke and I dont know if one will be required for the Alaska trip or if the Iphone will suffice?? Thanks....
No. If you can tell north from south without one you're golden. If you can't, you don't belong up there. Like Matteo said -- there's one road. What could go wrong?
-
Im leaning toward just purchasing the Garmin InReach and be done with it. Its expensive (In my opinion) and there is a monthly subscription service charge, but that should be all I ever need on any future trips too. :bike-037:
-
YES! There is NO cell service until you get to Deadhorse, then there is plenty. GET a "real" GPS ... It will have better sensitivity and higher reliability. It will tell you exactly where you are lost. Then again. There is ONLY 1 road between Fairbanks and DeadHorse.. The Elliot Highway from Fairbanks to The Dalton.. (Take a right) ... There are no other turns available.... :)
-
ALSO.. I am a big believer in "No single point of failures" If you combine all your requirements into 1 device. and that device fails, you have NOTHING. Splitting Phone, for communications and GPS, for navigation, makes a lot of sense to me.
-
GET a "real" GPS ... It will have better sensitivity and higher reliability.
Why do you think a so called real GPS is more sensitive? I tested a lot of GNSS devices in an RF chamber. Often the phone's were more sensitive, had better processors, and received more bands like Glonass as well as GPS.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
-
No. If you can tell north from south without one you're golden. If you can't, you don't belong up there. Like Matteo said -- there's one road. What could go wrong?
"What could go wrong?" .... ummm I nearly spit my coffee.
Should we tell travellers about the fifteen minute rule?
When you stop on the side of the road it takes about fifteen minutes for the scavangers (coyotes, wolves and bears) to smell the new meal? I'm not sure if this is true or not. I only ever stop for thirteen minutes at a time.
-
I was being facetious. If it can go wrong it might. But the wrong road to Deadhorse is kinda out of the spectrum. Exactly where on the road might be a good question, but it's not going to be answered with a cell-tower-based GPS.
-
I was being facetious. If it can go wrong it might. But the wrong road to Deadhorse is kinda out of the spectrum. Exactly where on the road might be a good question, but it's not going to be answered with a cell-tower-based GPS.
I recognize humour when I read it. That was funny.
I think OP has the message; cell phones are for towns. Alaska has much better coverage than this side of the border but there are still huge swaths that are dead ~ as far as my most recent memory goes. It isn't like coverage miraculously appears 30 kilometres west of Beaver Creek. I've stopped on more than several occasions (Canada side) for a motorist needing help. It never fails to surprise them that we can't just call for a tow truck. "I'll call when I get to the next town".
Next up: road conditions when it rains.....
-
I have the Garmin InReach Explorer and pay the subscription, and the extra for the medical evacuation. This service also enables sending text messages through satellite, so you do not need phone system coverage. I bought the cheapest plan and use it sparingly. I have the Garmin Earthmate app on my phone - and it works without the GPS being paired - and it even works in airplane mode.
I went on a dirtbike ride recently, but forgot the handheld GPS. I got around just fine, and laid down an accurate track all throughout the ride, just from the phone's GPS reception (while in airplane mode).
It's not a perfect setup, but I like the app quite a lot. I also like the ability to send text updates when I am outside coverage areas. My wife likes knowing that she can reach me if needed, and that I can call for help via satellite if needed.
When I went to Europe last year, I downloaded all the maps for free for Germany, Italy, Austria, and Switzerland. Then I had detailed maps for the whole trip without using any data services.
-
The most important thing to remember in a good Alaska rain is that you can only see the top of a pothole. The bottom, if there is one, is hidden. The consistency of the bottom can only be discovered by testing it. I've seen a lot of riders charge a wet spot to discover it's 18" deep and has a slippery clay or deep mud bottom. I hate stopping in that stuff to pick somebody else up just a little less than when it's me. I've put my fly rod to better use probing the road than catching fish.
The next thing is to not traverse a flooded road until you walk it (or send someone on ahead :evil:). You need to know the depth, direction of flow, and bottom before you try crossing it. 4" of fast moving water over clay is a challenge.
The mud sticks to head pipes and stains them. Mine are a rusty brown, but it's mineral plating, not rust -- smooth as ceramic coating. It sticks to everything else, too. You'll want to hose the bike down occasionally if the rain doesn't do it for you.
-
You do NOT need cell coverage for a phone GPS. Why do you think you do?
I have Android devices mounted in my vehicles with no cell service, they have great GPSs. All I need to do is load the maps on a memory card over WiFi beforehand. I have access to a number of great maps all loaded on my device. Some of them have great highway maps. Some have great offroad maps. Some have great highway routing features. Some have features that seek the twistiest roads between here and there. Some find the fastest. Some are just simple but detailed maps.
A regular GPS is lucky to have one mediocre map, and their idea of routing. If it is missing anything, too bad.
Are you saying Wayne that a cellphone has a GPS built in?
(I always thought the cellphone apps worked by navigating using the cell tower locations)
If you don't need cell coverage do you still need a Sim card?
Do you still need a service provider?
Thanks
Roy
A regular GPS is lucky to have one mediocre map, and their idea of routing. If it is missing anything, too bad.
This is something to be aware of, If you were travelling West on the Trans Canada going to Vancouver Island with an older model GPS it would completely miss Highway 17 a major new highway that could save you an hours travel. Even if you buy the latest model GPS there's no gaurante the map is up to date. The TomTom and Magelin I have get confused when I drive over this. If you bought a map from a service station it could be out of date also.
Good luck trying to find an address in a new sub-division.
Most people don't expect to have to upload a map for their new GPS
So many traps for young players.
-
There are two technologies calling themselves GPS these days. One is what you expect -- satellite fixes for position. The other uses cell tower fixes. I'm pretty sure the cell tower type is sucking up your dats quota for the month as it lays a slug trail to track you with. True GPS does neither. Obviously the global coverage of true satellite GPS is the better technology.
Either kind can be "standalone" or internet dependent. Standalone means you pack your chart set with you as downloaded files. They work with or without internet access. Internet dependent types rely on interaction with Google Maps or similar on-line mapping service. No internet access = no nav. My Android phone can use that "OK Google" thing to plot and start a trip in an urban area, but it ceases to work once I'm out of cell phone range.
A smart phone capable of loading apps and having a GPS (most smart phones and many tablets do) can use any number of nav programs. The programs of course have different dependencies and different features. I use a $25 app called SYGIC, which is GPS-based and standalone. It uses Tom-Tom maps and among its other features works with my Bluetooth headset and has HUD mode. Depending on how and why you use GPS, this gizmo might be what you want. There are more complicated products that will do about whatever you want in terms of trip planning, real-time notifications, finding a gas station, etc.
Personally, I think that unless you're certain you'll never be out of cell range, an internet-based or cell tower nav system doesn't make any sense. I also think it makes more sense to overbuy and discover useful features later rather than cheap out and limit yourself.
-
There are two technologies calling themselves GPS these days. One is what you expect -- satellite fixes for position. The other uses cell tower fixes. I'm pretty sure the cell tower type is sucking up your dats quota for the month as it lays a slug trail to track you with. True GPS does neither. Obviously the global coverage of true satellite GPS is the better technology.
Either kind can be "standalone" or internet dependent. Standalone means you pack your chart set with you as downloaded files. They work with or without internet access. Internet dependent types rely on interaction with Google Maps or similar on-line mapping service. No internet access = no nav. My Android phone can use that "OK Google" thing to plot and start a trip in an urban area, but it ceases to work once I'm out of cell phone range.
A smart phone capable of loading apps and having a GPS (most smart phones and many tablets do) can use any number of nav programs. The programs of course have different dependencies and different features. I use a $25 app called SYGIC, which is GPS-based and standalone. It uses Tom-Tom maps and among its other features works with my Bluetooth headset and has HUD mode. Depending on how and why you use GPS, this gizmo might be what you want. There are more complicated products that will do about whatever you want in terms of trip planning, real-time notifications, finding a gas station, etc.
Personally, I think that unless you're certain you'll never be out of cell range, an internet-based or cell tower nav system doesn't make any sense. I also think it makes more sense to overbuy and discover useful features later rather than cheap out and limit yourself.
Thanks for the info. I downloaded the SYGIC app and will try it out..........If I can figure out how it works, or if it needs a GPS or internet signal to actually work? Im slow when it comes to this tech stuff......Thanks again....
-
Are you saying Wayne that a cellphone has a GPS built in?
(I always thought the cellphone apps worked by navigating using the cell tower locations)
If you don't need cell coverage do you still need a Sim card?
Do you still need a service provider?
Thanks
Roy
This is something to be aware of, If you were travelling West on the Trans Canada going to Vancouver Island with an older model GPS it would completely miss Highway 17 a major new highway that could save you an hours travel. Even if you buy the latest model GPS there's no gaurante the map is up to date. The TomTom and Magelin I have get confused when I drive over this. If you bought a map from a service station it could be out of date also.
Good luck trying to find an address in a new sub-division.
Most people don't expect to have to upload a map for their new GPS
So many traps for young players.
Cell phones have true GNSS, GPS and Glonass location. They ALSO can locate off of cell towers and Wifi. So they have much MORE location accuracy then a stand alone GPS. Inside the house here I am getting 19 satellites.
The one gotcha is that cell phone owners typically use Google maps or such that need cell data. But that is easy to fix with any number of free or pay map apps that put the map data on the phone.
You do not need to activate the phone. And there are now many rugged phones out there. Look for Youtube videos of the Nomu phone. They use the thing as a hammer in one video, toss it in a pool. Toss it off a building. Still works. A lot of off road motorcyclists are getting those, not activating them, and using them as a GPS in the woods.
On the other hand, I have two dead Garmin waterproof GPS units on a shelf where I made the mistake of riding in the rain, and they flamed out. My Samsung on the other hand I dropped on a rock and it slid into a lake. I just picked it up, wiped it off, and kept taking photos. Don't say a Garmin is more rugged, they aren't.
-
There is really only one android phone to use and that is a MOTO G. How could you use another? I have bought several new for $20-30 for use with prepaid service and then never activated them. Run them in airplane mode with wifi service only. The gps works great. Install a micro SD card and load up the maps and other useful software.
I use Torque for reading my cars computer and then there is Scan16M 15RC USB which looks like it will read 15M/RC ECUs and Scan M5X which reads M5A ECU.
-
There are also several good speedo apps that use gps.
I am thinking of ditching the speedo on my Jackal and just using a moto g for the speedo. No speedo cable needed and accurate and has trip odometer too. I just need to make a mount with a charging plug and I can remove the moto g easily when the bike is parked.
-
Hello, that was an interesting intellectual challenge on my trip.. What if, as I was taking a leak by the side of the road, a bear or some other predator came out of the woods... What would I do? ... My Solution.. .. Keep the bike running.. pee close by, be ready to jump on and ride.. Regardless of clothing condition... :)
"What could go wrong?" .... ummm I nearly spit my coffee.
Should we tell travellers about the fifteen minute rule?
When you stop on the side of the road it takes about fifteen minutes for the scavangers (coyotes, wolves and bears) to smell the new meal? I'm not sure if this is true or not. I only ever stop for thirteen minutes at a time.
-
Wayne:
I have been in numerous situation where my iPhone doesn't know where I am, but my Garmin does.. Mostly in Remote places... LIKE: The British Virgin Islands, where cell service is spotty and GPS is LOCKED ON... I do rely on Cell/GPS in a major city, but one beyond a metro area.. There is nothing like a "settled' GPS ..
Why do you think a so called real GPS is more sensitive? I tested a lot of GNSS devices in an RF chamber. Often the phone's were more sensitive, had better processors, and received more bands like Glonass as well as GPS.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
-
I have been in numerous situation where my iPhone doesn't know where I am, but my Garmin does.. Mostly in Remote places... LIKE: The British Virgin Islands, where cell service is spotty and GPS is LOCKED ON... I do rely on Cell/GPS in a major city, but one beyond a metro area.. There is nothing like a "settled' GPS ..
What offline map data where you using? What app?
I can't speak for whacky iPhones. I know my Android devices have a true GPS, and when used with maps stored on the phone, it is better in most ways than a Garmin.
-
Hello, that was an interesting intellectual challenge on my trip.. What if, as I was taking a leak by the side of the road, a bear or some other predator came out of the woods... What would I do? ... My Solution.. .. Keep the bike running.. pee close by, be ready to jump on and ride.. Regardless of clothing condition... :)
Hope you had a great trip and made some great memories. You know, we welcome people back for more.
I travel these roads for work a fair amount. This is about the most accurate picture you'll see of an animal's response to humans in the area.
(http://thumb.ibb.co/cNK3b6/wolf_blk_young.jpg) (http://ibb.co/cNK3b6)
-
Thanks for the info. I downloaded the SYGIC app and will try it out..........If I can figure out how it works, or if it needs a GPS or internet signal to actually work? Im slow when it comes to this tech stuff......Thanks again....
Sygic works without cell phone or Internet service, as long as you have already downloaded the appropriate maps (important!). The interface for this is a bit funky, since the Europeans who built the tool call each state or section a 'country' - they're used to smaller countries from their experience. Sygic uses the built-in true GPS of more modern phones, not the cell location signal from towers. As Wayne and others have said, the phone's GPS capability can be as accurate (10 meter resolution nominally) as a stand-alone GPS.
One thing to note - any location service running continually on a phone will significantly increase battery usage, so plan on using a power feed!
Personally, I still run a separate GPS and have the Sygic setup for a backup.
-
10 meters (12') of location drift in modern satellite gps would be very low quality. It's more like 1/2 meter (18") with most true GPS. Mine shows a change in position when my boat bobs in the water. It knows when I got off the left side of the trike v the right side. With that fine a resolution, what do you need with MORE accuracy? In my opinion, using cell towers as well as GPS is a ploy by the consumer demons to suck up your data quota and tell THEM where you are. It also uses even more battery than GPS alone. I don't use my data link unless I'm actually looking for data -- weather, WG, news, that sort of thing. If I can't find open wireless, I try to tough it out till I can.
Yes, SYGIC requires a GPS to find position, but it does not require cell service except to download the program and charts. You can get all of NA, including Mexico onto most any phone.
A caveat about SYGIC -- it's been very successful. That means there are counterfeits out there. Be sure you're getting yours from a legitimate outlet (google play). If you're not sure, go to the SYGIC website and follow the official links.
And yes, even with my previous hi-cap battery phone I could not get 8 hours out of a charge when using GPS. Early on I plumbed in a small (150w) A/C inverter that included a couple of USB ports. I took one USB to the handlebar for normal GPS work and routed the other to a little compartment over a fuel tank. When the weather sucks I put the phone in the compartment and just listen for nav over the headset.
How you attach the device to the bike is another bucket of bones. We could have a thread for nothing but the methods and devices out there for mounting phones, GPS units and tablets to bikes. HINT -- still working on it.
-
Wayne.
My point is with my GPS I can always use a Lat and Long to determine my position on a paper chart. I don't need internal maps internal / downloaded maps, I only need a position and then I can plot my fix and navigate from there with a simple compass and watch. It is nice to have downloaded maps or charts, it is convenient, but Lat and Long are the ultimate navigational tool.. Along with the two things that DON"T relay on electricity.. my Compass and my common sense.
What offline map data where you using? What app?
I can't speak for whacky iPhones. I know my Android devices have a true GPS, and when used with maps stored on the phone, it is better in most ways than a Garmin.
-
My point is with my GPS I can always use a Lat and Long to determine my position on a paper chart. I don't need internal maps internal / downloaded maps, I only need a position and then I can plot my fix and navigate from there with a simple compass and watch. It is nice to have downloaded maps or charts, it is convenient, but Lat and Long are the ultimate navigational tool.. Along with the two things that DON"T relay on electricity.. my Compass and my common sense.
Like this? Easy.
That is indoors, so the accuracy is poor.
Probably wasted my time blanking out a bit of the coordinates. :boozing:
(http://thumb.ibb.co/gBPEvc/Screenshot_20180206_174457.jpg) (http://ibb.co/gBPEvc)
-
After Wayne's post I thought I would try turning the data off on my I-phone 6, sure enough the GPS still worked but the maps would disappear after a minute or so when you move off the edge. From that I concluded that the phone downloads the data to draw the map chewing up data in the process.
I wish I had known about the android thing before I bought a new TomTom GPS, oh well.
-
For my back-up, I do my route maps on my iPad then take a screen shot. Works ok for me.
-
I do my route planning on paper and my "backup" is my road atlas. The GPS maps help me inspect details. I try to collect the gas-station-type folding maps for the states I travel through. I use the GPS more for turn-by-turn navigation, finding gas, and doing quick snoops of the "road not taken" to see if I want to take it.
The old windjammers had a map holder on the compartment covers. I miss that.