Ben, you need to think about where you'll be asking your scrambler to take you on your various rides. If you will be taking on mostly street and some mild off-road terrain from time to time, then a tire that is constructed to give you 80% street/20% dirt usage is what you need. If you will be doing more dirt/gravel than street, then obviously you'll need a tire constructed for that usage. I loved the Pirelli MT60's on my Ducati Scrambler. They were excellent road holders, decent on light trails, good in the wet, but, I never got great mileage out of them. The tire companies have made great progress in building really good tires to suit a riders taste and pocketbook. You may need to spend time in tire catalogs at a good dealer. Pay attention to the correct wheel sizes and various ratio aspects you have decided you want for your riding needs. Write down your choices and then go look them up on your computer for reviews......... questions from knowledgeable people. It worked for me ! The Kid