Loop frame vs. modern

[Antietam Classic Cycle]

Loop drum brakes will never be "two-finger" brakes, so if that is your expectation, then move on to fitting a disc front end or buy an entirely different bike.

I'm not sure that I'd choose a Loop of any sort as a "stop-and-go traffic commuter bike". I know there are folks that do it, but I'd choose something disposable, cheap and appliance-like for that.

My advice to Eric: if you want a Loop, buy one and save it for the fun rides. Use something else for the "daily grind".

[Yeahoo Whoyah]

Eric I see you're in SoCal. This bike is about 400-miles north of you but might fit your needs. A loop with modern touches ready to ride. With SoCal traffic good brakes are everything.
http://sfbay.craigslist.org/pen/mcy/5542961398.html

[Muzz]

I never had a SB and don't have any desire for one..

I have never had a BB and don't have any desire for one.

As a bit of explanation, I only have one bike so it has to do everything. The SB's are easier to handle around town, and are great fun in the tight twisties. The SB WILL tour. Must qualify that by saying that out here our roads have corners, and lots of them, so the SB will have you with a permanent grin on your face.

I have sat on BB's, and would have to say that I felt (all 5ft 7" of me)  much more at home on the small block.

[Chuck in Indiana]

Yeah, Muzz.. that's something we haven't addressed for the OP. We got caught up in braking capabilities, and glossed over the small block. It's a perfectly capable do everything bike, and a better "city" bike than a big block. You have to remember the older small blocks were built to a price, and need a loving hand to sort them. As far as I know, the modern small blocks are as reliable as anything else.

[charlie b]

I also have only one bike, a "BB".  Easily runs around town as it is what I commute with, run errands, and tour.  The seat can be as low as you want with a custom made for you.  Change it to look and perform however you want, or buy one already set up the way you want.  I'd not want anything smaller.  :)