I can tell you first hand to not put an Eldo engine together with used rod bolts. 
Really? I reuse the rod bolts in just about every engine I rebuild and have never had a failure! I measure each one and compare it to a NOS one I have, if any are stretched or otherwise damaged, I don't reuse them.
The new ones are of substandard quality - at first they fit into the rods very loosely, then the next batch were too tight. Maybe they've corrected the issue by now. I do wonder where they're really made - likely China.
I had a friend that worked in the testing lab of a truck powertrain company test used original and aftermarket bolts to failure. The used original was substantially stronger.
To answer 70Ambo21V7's question, I'd use the set on the left.